Can you write a little on how you are able to tell how much to invest in holding a position before you decide to switch, i.e. how much of your game is based on controlling your opponent and implementing YOUR game plan vs complete reaction to their movements; and how has that changed as you progressed?
Great question!
Saulo has a great quote:
“If you have to think, your late. If your late, you muscle. If you muscle, you get tired. If you get tired, you die.”
The way I interpret thinking here, is he’s talking about extremely high level BJJ where people’s attacks are reflexive. If your posture and defense aren’t just as ingrained, guess who’s going to lose?
In terms of holding positions, for the sake of pure BJJ I don’t think it is wise to invest anything. Why? Because once you start investing, you tense. To steal Saulo’s theme, the more tense you are, the less relaxed. The less relaxed you are, the less aware.
Awareness predicates intelligent response.
What you can do study-wise, is research when positioning is solid and why? This is the mechanical aspect of BJJ.
For example, when you have harness/head-and-arm control from cross-side top, with head buried to prevent framing, you have excellent positioning. Why? Because you’ve taken away the far-side frame, and essentially made yourself a part of the person on bottom.
If you start investing though, rather than relaxing and molding to your opponent, you increase the odds of being rolled, especially with a grappler who has 50 lbs. + on you. The bigger the weight, size, and strength difference, the more you’ll have to rely on sensitivity, and movement stay out of guard and on top.
That’s it really. From the outside looking in, it may look like I have a game plan, but what I’m looking to do has more to do with physics, mechanics, and awareness than trying to fit a round peg in a square hole.
In terms of my evolution, up until brown I tried to force things, and still catch myself doing it now, so it’s a matter of taking my own advice. When you have a knowledge advantage you can force things, but this approach is a death-wish among savvy brown and black belts.
Over-committing will eventually lead to this: